love it! but you need to use a separate sharpener
"I had to laugh when I saw other people's reviews about not being able to get more eye liner pencil to come out.... because I also couldn't figure it out and almost threw it away!! I was so frustrated!!! Then I got to thinking about it.... the company certainly wouldn't sell it to be used only once.... so I got out my own separate eye pencil sharpener and tried it out & suddenly realized that the problem was not the eye pencil, but not realizing I just needed to sharpen it! I do love this eye pencil!! It has a little sparkle to it... I purchased the gray and will definitely be buying it again!"